Post 5: Ecocriticism

From what I have gathered from the Purdue Online Writing Lab as well as a neat youtube video quickly explaining eco-criticism, ecocriticism is the study of the relationship between literature (and other media) and nature. As more simply put, it “takes an earth centered approach to literary studies” (Cheryll Glotfelty). First rising in the 1980’s, there are two waves to this movement: The first movement focused more on raising awareness and creating physically and culturally informed solutions to environmental crises that we have today and the second wave,  which blurs the boundaries between human and non-human, and seems to have a pinch of Critical Race Theory integrated into it as class, race, and gender are all considered when reading a ecocritical text. I feel like I will be analyzing media using the second wave approach more, as we delve into ecological crises and who is “to blame” and who is affected the most in each scenario. 

Regarding the snickers commercial, it less so addressed what was actually wrong in the world (wealth inequality, climate change, etc.) and instead took a full minute and fifteen seconds to take multiple jabs at those in modern society simply just living their lives (riding scooters, sending private pictures, naming children after produce (which, while I find a bit odd, is ultimately harmless)). And the legitimate reasons to be worried in this world that are mentioned in this video (the concerns in politics, heavy surveillance) are all overlooked and made into jokes, as if they are meant to happen in this modern society (being mixed within the list of mundane “annoyances”). 

It was hard to not take this video as an insult. There are so many things Snickers could have actually addressed, but this video instead mainly took jabs at mundane occurrences and then “resolved” everything by giving the world snickers. There were so many signs to indicate that whoever made this commercial very much didn’t really care? But the biggest indicator was the exchange between the boy and the man, with the boy asking if feeding the world snickers will work and the man simply shrugging. This attempt to be self aware comes off moreso as indifferent, as if saying “we know it won’t work, but here’s what we find ANNOYING in the world. Buy our product!”. In this commercial, nature is more or less disregarded with more attention focused on societal matters.

References

8 thoughts on “Post 5: Ecocriticism”

  1. I agree with you, I found this ad to be a waste of time, and honestly in poor taste. From an eco-critic’s perspective, I actually think it’s destructive to the world. All these people destroying the woods going to the hole, the act of dropping trash into the earth, and all this just to ultimately attract attention to Snickers and suggest that somehow that will stop small problems.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Hi Alex,
    I really liked the additional media that you added to your blog. Regarding your take on the snickers commercial I completely agree with what you were saying about how it didn’t seem to really address climate and environmental issues but more so social issues. Overall I really liked and agreed with your post!
    Great job

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I really liked your highlight of the conversation the little kid had about if it’ll work, referring to the snickers being dropped. Really one of the things that stood out to me was hey were solving the world’s problems by creating more. What I mean in that is using the helicopter to drop this massive candy, wrapped in PLASTIC, into a hole in the earth. When are we going to stop abusing the earth in order to serve us better instead of fixing us in order to help the earth.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Great point, Laura. If you take the ad at its literal face, it’s about committing a giant act of eco-destruction. (Big holes are terrible for local ecosystems. See everything written about open-pit mining.)
      Thanks!

      Like

  4. Hi Alex,

    I like the stand you took on the ad and pointing out how it really doest highlight nature but more just what random people are doing and using technology. As you point it out this ad really didn’t care and you are probably right in how snickers could have done so much more. Loved the videos and help me understand thanks for sharing with the class.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Hi Alex I totally agree with your take on the Snickers commercial. It made a jab at the mundane things people do from day to day just living their lives and kind of left out the big issues that need to be addressed in todays society, like global warming, wealth inequality and so on. I guess it just goes to show that people like to be distracted from the big issues in the world so as to sleep better at night, I guess you could say. Anyways, great post.

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Hello alex,

    I Love the videos I had a really hard time understanding 2ed wave Ecocriticism from the reading alone, likely due to its broad nature.

    I really find your comments about the commercial really interesting, and I agree with all of your points the strongest one being how much I hate the conversation between the child and the man. Although I was not insulted by the ad I just thought of it as a dumb chimerical. but your comments and points make me wonder if I should think of it more chimericals more critically in the future

    Liked by 1 person

  7. It was super insulting. Thanks for noticing! You sum it up well here:
    “Regarding the snickers commercial, it less so addressed what was actually wrong in the world (wealth inequality, climate change, etc.) and instead took a full minute and fifteen seconds to take multiple jabs at those in modern society simply just living their lives (riding scooters, sending private pictures, naming children after produce (which, while I find a bit odd, is ultimately harmless)). And the legitimate reasons to be worried in this world that are mentioned in this video (the concerns in politics, heavy surveillance) are all overlooked and made into jokes, as if they are meant to happen in this modern society (being mixed within the list of mundane “annoyances”). ”
    Yup!
    Boo, Snickers, boo.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free